5 Times Star Wars Had Fire In Space: The internet should acknowledge that Star Wars has always had fire in space. Lucasfilm’s latest Star Wars Disney+ TV program, The Acolyte, has sparked debate over a scene in which Amandla Stenberg’s Mae fights a space fire. Mae, a Meknek who works with Pip, knows how to fix the issue.
5 Times Star Wars Had Fire In Space
Should it be a problem? Space doesn’t allow fire to burn since it needs oxygen. Flames should behave strangely and beautifully without gravity. The Acolyte ignores this, and viewers slammed the scene. However, it’s a good Star Wars tradition.
1. The Attack On The First Death Star
Flames in space make it easy to notice that the Death Star conflict breaches all physics. The script clearly describes Rebel shots destroying artillery emplacements and radars:
Lucas copied the fireball explosions of TIE Fighters and X-wings from World War II movies and dogfights, regardless of scientific accuracy. Luke sends R2-D2 to extinguish flames on his ship. The Acolyte implies Mae is an Astromech as she spacewalks to extinguish the fire.
2. The Crash Of The Executor
The Executor’s fire is the most visible in space, but the Second Death Star also burns. The Rebel Alliance weaponizes Darth Vader’s Super Star Destroyer, the strongest ship in the Imperial fleet, against the Death Star. They destroy the bridge, and the Super Star Destroyer hits the Death Star, causing massive devastation.
Flames on the Executor in Return of the Jedi aren’t subtle. Worse, the bridge explosion has no vacuum effect. Lucas prioritized the “Rule of Cool” and wanted everything to look great over real-life physics.
Also See:Â
A Republican Election Clerk vs. Trump Die-Hards in a World of Lies
3. The Destruction Of The Droid Command Center
Science wasn’t important to Lucas in the Star Wars prequel trilogy either. As Anakin Skywalker flies away triumphantly, the Trade Federation droid command ship explodes in Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace, purposely paralleling the first Death Star’s destruction.
This explosion takes longer, as flame spouts are repeatedly exposed to space’s vacuum and are unharmed. scientific fiction—not scientific fantasy. That allowed George Lucas to do whatever he wanted if it looked cool. It wasn’t a mistake in 1999 or today.
4. The Battle of Coruscant
The Battle of Coruscant is considered a Star Wars classic. Anakin and Obi-Wan fly into a storm to rescue Chancellor Palpatine in the third prequel movie’s stunning beginning.
There are several fireballs, and capital ships’ hulls burn as they take fire, defying physics. Additionally, the entire event is taking place outside Coruscant’s atmosphere, thus there’s no excuse but the “Rule of Cool.”
5. The Destruction Of The Droid Command Center
Nowhere in Star Wars is space without fire. Every explosion behaves in an atmosphere, not a vacuum. From Rogue One to Star Wars: The Clone Wars, deadly starfighters and massive ships burn. Additionally, most science-fiction films and TV shows follow George Lucas’ lead in bypassing physics in favor of the “Rule of Cool.”
Not an issue. George Lucas expects audiences to suspend disbelief and enjoy the show. Why are those who criticize The Acolyte now unwilling to suspend disbelief in this case? The problem is likely aired in bad faith; they don’t want to suspend their disbelief and wish to find the latest Star Wars TV show weak. Ironically, this disagreement has a genuine point.
